Melissa’s Place

It was Andrew Loyd Webber night, the broadway theme was perfect for Syesha and David Archuleta but probably hurt the most for Jason and Brooke.

Here are my thoughts starting with my favourite:

1. David Archuleta - David sang Phantom Of  The Opera’s ‘Think Of Me’ and turned it into a pop ballad. I thought he was the most original of the night and despite what Simon said I thought it sounded pretty perfect.
2. Syesha Mercado - Syesha sand ‘One Rock And Roll Too Many’. She had a lot of fun with this song. Broadway is definitely her Genre.
3. David Cook - David sang Phantom Of The Opera’s ‘Music Of The Night’ and proved that he really is a very dynamic performer. My husband thought he should have dressed up as a vampire. I think only Jacob Hoggard from Canadian Idol would have done that. 
4. Brooke White - Brooke sang Evita’s ‘You Must Love Me’. Apart from Brooke stopping 8 seconds into the song then asking to start over again, She sang it well. The last few performances she has been so nervous I don’t know what happened. In her earlier performances she seemed relaxed and upbeat. She is my favourite contestant so I do hope she stays.
5. Jason Castro - Jason sang Memory and I really didn’t like it all. Broadway is definitely not his style.
6. Carly Smithson - Carly sang ‘Jesus Christ Superstar’, she did well I just really didn’t like the song. I think a song about Christ should be more reverant, not a rock song. Just my opinion.

I predict the bottom three will be Carly, Brooke and Jason with either Brooke or Jason leaving. I will be sad if Brooke leaves

Bookmark to: